Context: https://brickadia.com/contests/planes-contest
The theme for this contest is planes! Build something in-game that's drivable and flyable! Whether it's a car or a boat, make it fly! Get people to vote on your submission by sharing either by word of mouth or social media!
Nominations: November 15th - November 22nd
Nominate a finalist for the final week of voting while submissions are still open!
Finalists: November 22nd - November 25th
Vote for which finalist submission you want to see win!
Community Choice Voting. Eligible Contest entries will also be available for public voting through the Brickadia Gallery from November 15th at 3:00 PM ET through November 25th at 3:00 PM ET (the “Voting Period”). Each Brickadia account may cast one (1) vote during the Voting Period. Contest entrants may participate in voting, including voting for their own entry.
Yet with all that legal garbage they managed to neglect defining "nomination". "Finalist" is not defined there either. Based on how they defined "voting period", the "one vote" applies both to nomination and the finalists, but only the "finalist" period mentions "voting". WHAT THE **** IS A NOMINATION THEN? DOES EACH VOTER GET UNLIMITED NOMINATIONS? Fucking idiots. I can't even frame my argument securely because I can't tell how this is supposed to be executed.
This is not voting for a politician. Voting in this is an entirely inconsequential decision with little cost other than a few minutes and in an environment where many players know each other, creating strong social forces. Therefore, I believe the prevailing force for gaining the most votes would be the ability for single contestants to motivate the most people. This will probably have a heavy bias towards those (the monoliths) with the most friends or "followers" (orbiters). Orbiters are great in number and tend to cluster around a small amount of monoliths. The "recluse" knows few people and can be either a contestant or voter.
For the sake of argument, I assume the worst case for making a decision: all contest submissions are somehow roughly equal in quality and ranking, as if there is somehow an objective judgement of such. The idea is that there may be minute details that sway voters, but not enough to prevail over other forces.
The "orbiter" knows he has one vote and probably wants to see his "monolith" win as a personal service or appreciation.
The "recluse" contestants must rely on merit and don't really have anyone voting for them as a personal service. The recluse contestants must somehow get the individual votes of many recluse voters. The recluse contestant will presumably not gather many orbiter votes because the orbiters had only one vote that they spent on their monoliths. If the orbiters greatly outnumber recluse voters, these recluse contestants don't have a chance.
The way you might be able to dilute the prevailing force of this orbiter-monolith bias is to split the process into multiple rounds where at a minimum the first one is approval voting.
In the first round, allow everyone to vote for any amount of submissions or define some decent limit, perhaps 5. The orbiters may vote for their monoliths anyway, but they may genuinely like other submissions and vote on those as well. The orbiter is no longer strongly encouraged by his social connections to give all of his voting power to 1 recipient. Finally, you decide the first round of winners by taking the top 10 candiates with most amount of votes.
The second/final round can be normal first-past-the-post system because you would hope to have overpowered the initial selection bias after the first round. If a large amount of recluse voters converged on a small amount of recluse contestants in that first round, these submissions now have a chance as everyone will be making further selections only from a pool of top 10. Some proportion of orbiters may no longer have their monoliths in the contest and no longer have a "bound" vote, so any choice they make (if they still care to vote) is no longer within the orbiter-monolith bias.
all that logic to discuss a shitty reward for a game that's slowly moving to a roblox-like experience where you win exclusive cosmetics